 |
| MLB The Show 26 puts Aaron Judge front and centre and Road to the Show behind him for a reason. The amateur years are the best part of the mode this year. |
By Juli Scarr
I've been a Blue Jays fan my whole life. Every spring, that means two things: real baseball is back, and so is MLB The Show. This year I loaded up MLB The Show 26 on PlayStation 5 expecting the usual mix of familiar and new. What I didn't expect was how quickly the on-field decisions started feeling different. By the second inning of my first game, I was already thinking harder than I had in years about when to pitch, how to build my defence, and whether my catcher could actually hold the running game together.
That is a genuinely good sign for this series.
MLB The Show 26 Details
Platform: PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S, Nintendo Switch
Reviewed on: PlayStation 5
Developer: San Diego Studio
Publisher: Sony Interactive Entertainment, MLB Advanced Media
Genre: Sports / Baseball Simulation
Game Modes: Single-player, Multiplayer
The On-Field Game Has Never Asked This Much of You
The biggest changes in MLB The Show 26 don't hit you all at once. They creep in, one at a time, until you look up midway through a game and realise you're playing baseball differently than you ever have before.
Bear Down Pitching Changes How You Manage the Mound
Bear Down Pitching is the clearest example. You get a limited supply of focus you can activate on the mound during critical moments. Use it and your pitch gains extra velocity and tighter control. The concept is simple enough. But knowing when to use it is the whole game. You have to think about whether to use it early when a jam is building, or save it for the moment later in the game when everything hangs on one pitch. It won't rescue a mistake. Throw a bad pitch and it's still a bad pitch. I got this wrong plenty of times before I started getting it right.
Hitting Gets More Tools Than Any Previous Entry
Hitting got a significant overhaul too. Big Zone Hitting gives you a larger contact area to work with, making it easier to get the bat on the ball without demanding the exact placement of traditional zone hitting. It's not going to take over competitive play. You can't land perfect-perfect contact with it. But for anyone who has struggled with the demands of the standard hitting system, this is a genuinely better way in than directional hitting has ever been.
The new PCI Sensitivity slider is worth your time too. The PCI — Point of Contact Indicator — is the cursor you drag around the strike zone when timing your swing. The new slider lets you dial in exactly how quickly it responds to your input. I fiddled with it early on and found a setting that clicked. The difference showed up in my results almost immediately.
Defence Gets a Complete Rethink
The directional split system for fielding reaction time is the change I didn't see coming and the one that affected my games the most. Reaction time used to be one number. Now it's four: forward, backward, left, and right. My shortstop has a weak rating going left. I know this because I watched him get beaten twice in the same game by balls headed toward the middle. So now I think about my second baseman differently. I need him moving well to his right to cover that gap. Building a defence has become as interesting as building a lineup, and that's not something I've been able to say about this series before.
Catcher pop time is now its own separate rating too. I tested this directly. With a weak catcher behind the plate, opposing runners took off on me constantly. I swapped in an elite option and the stolen base attempts dried up almost immediately. It's a small change that makes a real difference when a game is on the line.
Road to the Show Finally Starts at the Beginning
Road to the Show has been one of my favourite modes in this series for years. This year it got the biggest overhaul it's ever had. Instead of jumping straight into the minor leagues, you start in high school. Then college. Then the MLB Draft Combine. Then the fully licensed NCAA College World Series. Then, finally, professional baseball. The College World Series bracket is the highlight. Charles Schwab Field in Omaha looks the part, and the crowd noise carries in a way a standard minor league game never manages. The whole amateur arc gives you a reason to actually care about your player before they ever put on a professional uniform.
The Road to Cooperstown system connects every early decision you make to your long-term Hall of Fame legacy. Even games that would have felt like filler in previous years now carry actual stakes.
The major league side of the career hasn't caught up yet. When you finally reach the pros, some of the momentum the early years build just isn't there. But Road to the Show has never been in a better place than it is right now.
Franchise Mode Gets What It Needed
Franchise players have been waiting a long time for a meaningful update. MLB The Show 26 comes through. The Trade HUB is the centrepiece. It pulls together rumour tracking, league-wide negotiation monitoring, and deal pursuit into one interface. Trades now take time to develop. Teams evaluate before committing. Landing a genuine star takes real planning rather than finding the right shortcut. I found myself thinking through roster moves more carefully this year than in any previous entry, and that's exactly the point.
Custom Game Entry is the other practical addition. You can drop directly into the key games of your season without playing through every low-stakes April matchup. The long haul of a franchise season stays interesting from start to finish.
Diamond Dynasty Is at Its Best on Day One
If Diamond Dynasty is your mode, this is the best the game has ever looked at launch. The World Baseball Classic integration brings over 130 new cards to chase, full tournament play from the pool stage through to the championship, and the option to enter your Diamond Dynasty roster to compete for a nation. Red Diamond cards introduce a new elite rarity tier above the existing diamond hierarchy. Parallel Mods let you specialise cards with contact, power, fielding, or speed upgrades as you parallel them up. Every new card drop becomes a decision rather than just a collection update.
Team Affinity is better organized than last year. Every team has a hitter captain and a pitcher captain available from day one, which wasn't the case in MLB The Show 25. Removing stats like durability that had no real gameplay impact from card ratings means the number you see on a card now actually reflects what matters. The grind is still the grind. But for anyone who plays Diamond Dynasty seriously, this is the most content the mode has ever had waiting on launch day.
A Familiar Look With a Few New Touches
On PlayStation 5, MLB The Show 26 hits 4K 60fps with HDR turned on. The game looks good. The jersey physics are a nice new addition and the stadium environments are well reproduced. But it's still the same base package this series has been running with for the past few years. Edge aliasing hasn't gone away. The crowds don't look like a current-generation sports title should. And there's no PlayStation 5 Pro support, which is hard to understand for a release coming straight from PlayStation's own studio.
The commentary gets more specific this year, with dialogue that responds better to what's actually happening in the game. Robert Flores handling mode-specific commentary adds variety to the broadcast. The authentic pitch call audio coming through the controller is a new touch I didn't keep on for long. It felt like extra noise rather than something that added to the experience, though I imagine some players will leave it running.
One issue worth flagging: I ran into a bug where foul balls occasionally registered as home runs. A patch should take care of it, but it's worth knowing going in.
MLB The Show 26 Is the Best the Series Has Ever Felt
This is the version of MLB The Show I've been waiting for. The on-field strategy changes build on each other in a way that makes every game feel more connected than previous entries. Road to the Show has never given you this much reason to care about your player from the very first game. Franchise Mode finally works the way it always should have. Diamond Dynasty has never come out of the gate with this much to do.
The visuals haven't moved much and the foul ball bug needs fixing. Neither of those things change what this game is. Every year I fire up the Blue Jays and play the same way I always have. MLB The Show 26 is the first entry in years that made me change that approach. That tells you everything.
MLB The Show 26 Review Summary
Liked
- Bear Down Pitching and directional fielding splits make every on-field decision matter more than ever before
- Road to the Show's high school and college arc is the most complete the mode has ever been
- Catcher pop time as its own rating changes how you build and manage your roster
- Diamond Dynasty launches with more content than it has ever had on day one
- Franchise Mode's Trade HUB finally gives you the deal-making system the mode always needed
- Strong overall value for both returning fans and anyone jumping in for the first time
Didn't Like
- Visuals haven't moved meaningfully from last year and there are no PlayStation 5 Pro enhancements
- The professional side of Road to the Show loses energy once you reach the majors
- Foul ball home run bug needs a patch
- Diamond Dynasty grind remains heavy for casual players
Overall Assessment of MLB The Show 26
Gameplay: ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ (4.5 / 5)
Presentation: ⭐⭐⭐✨☆ (3.5 / 5)
Performance: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (4 / 5)
Story / Narrative: ⭐⭐⭐✨☆ (3.5 / 5)
Fun Factor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ (4.5 / 5)
Overall Value: ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ (4.5 / 5)
Comments
Post a Comment
Comments are moderated. Please stay respectful and on topic.